Employee Benefit Trust

Learn About An EBT Beating Alternative

Employee Benefit Trust, The Right Choice?The Employee Benefit Trust has been a popular alternative to the Umbrella Company for many years. Hundreds if not thousands of self employed contractors and other high net worth professionals (such as those in the creative arts) have taken advantage of the higher rates of pay that can be achieved via the use of an Employee Benefit Trust payroll solution. Where as a typical Umbrella Company gives a gross to net contract ratio of around 65% many EBT solutions offer a return of up to 85%. The opportunity to keep an extra 20% of YOUR pay has been seen as a massive bonus to high earners.

Employee Benefit Trusts also became popular because of the added security they offered. By using an Employee Benefit Trust and becoming an employee scheme members were granted full statutory employment rights and benefits. The lack of a need to keep complicated expense details also endeared this solution to those who preferred to spend more of their time earning money instead of doing paperwork. This was a massive advantage over those that either used an Umbrella Company or who chose to setup their own Limited Company. At this point you’re probably thinking that an Employee Benefit Trusts sounds too good to be true, how come everybody isn’t using them?

The answer to the second question is simple. In order to gain any advantage from an EBT you really need to be earning above a certain level. Some scheme providers set this level at 40,000 a year, others at 50,000 a year. The too good to be true bit is a little harder to explain. In essence it comes down to risk. Employee Benefit Trusts were so tax efficient because of the nature of the loan payment that was given to the employee (i.e. the contractor). The contractor was paid a basic salary and the rest of the money was “loaned”. Because this was paid as a loan (and not as salary) there was no guarantee that the loan wouldn’t be called in. Of course all providers marketed that this wouldn’t happen and that they had various methods of making sure the loan wouldn’t be asked to be repaid. Fine unless the payroll provider encounters money problems which could result in the loan being sold as an asset. Could you imagine the company that now owns that debt not asking for the money back? As far as the legalities go there has been a split with regard to EBTs. The general consensus appears to be that those that are based onshore whilst those offshore were effective.

So even with all the advantages that an Employee Benefit Trust offers their popularity has declined massively.For many contractors the risks associated with an EBT are seen to out way the advanatges. A scenario that has not been helped by several scheme providers being investigated by HMRC. The question is what alternatives are there? The governments stance on contractors seems to go against encouraging innovation and excellence within business. How can you expect people to take the risks associated with working for yourself if the bottom line is no better than being employed to do the same job(minus paid holidays, pension)? It’s all too easy for Civil Servants in comfy 35 hours a week, 30 days a year holiday, final salary pensioned posts to interfere in areas of business where they have little understanding. It is every contractors duty to be paid in a legally compliant tax efficient manner and Employee Benefit Trusts have played there part in this process in the past.


Comments are closed.